Neil Grossman writes,

Banning abortion essentially gives the state custody of a pregnant woman’s uterus. That’s not a politically correct way to put it, but it’s what a ban entails. Under such laws, if a woman gets pregnant, she loses the right to control what happens inside her body. If she doesn’t want to carry to term and give birth, the government forces her to against her will. That means the state, not the pregnant woman, has custody of her body. Otherwise, she, not government, would get to decide what happens inside her uterus, and whether the rest of her body should go through the physical changes and health risks that accompany pregnancy. (

The government prevents me from injecting heroin into my body. By Grossman’s logic it seems the government already has custody of my body and everyone else’s.

Many years ago Paul Manata mentioned the following hypothetical: what if I sowed a bomb under my skin. Can the government prevent me from detonating it?

Or suppose a child wants to smoke cigarettes and the parents consent. Or suppose a child wants her perfectly healthy arm amputated and the parents consent. If Grossman thinks the government can prevent it, then ultimately it is the government that has custody of all children.

If Grossman thinks that the government preventing you from doing something to your body (to someone in your body) means that the government has custody of your body, then okay, that’s sometimes a good and necessary element to social welfare. But I suspect Grossmen would resist the characterization in those cases because he’s really trying to to make it sound scary and therefore bad. It’s a “Boo!” argument.



Throwing half-baked ideas against the wall and seeing what sticks.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Questions From The Black Manosphere

The Power of Connection

What is the Red Pill?

R. Kelly and the Myth of The Pied Piper

Ten Critical Lessons White Men can Learn From Angela Davis

Stairways to Enlightenment

Aiming High: A New Group Of Women Rise To The Challenge Of Gender Equality In Burkina Faso

Armchair activism, slacktivism, conservatism

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
John Bowling

John Bowling

Throwing half-baked ideas against the wall and seeing what sticks.

More from Medium


Transcript —Nature’s Harsh Truths in Outer Wilds and Rain World

When Being Selfless is Selfish

Cigarettes and Angel Food Cake